The Bright Old Oak

Inspiration is the key!

Fighting melancholy in the 21st Century


I’m in London. The capital ciy of rain, perhaps. That’s all I’ve seen in the last few days anyway! To live here means facing the world with a brave smile upon your face and a perseverance in trying to cast those dark clouds away. Luckily (or unfortunately, in some cases), we’re now surrounded by many different things which can help our mood in case of constant bad weather. I’ve never really had this problem, until a couple of years ago, when I realised weather had started to influence my better judgment. What about the past? In 1820 Sydney Smith sent a letter to Lady Georgiana Morpeth. He listed 20 tips to help her avoid suffering from ‘low spirits’, which is what we call ‘melancholy’, I’m guessing. Curiously, no mention of the great British weather, but there are a few eference on keeping oneself warm! So, here’s the list as it was compiled, followed by my opinion on each point.

1st. Live as well as you dare.
Well, this is an all-time classic, really. But one also needs to be wise!
2nd. Go into the showerbath with a small quantity of water at a temperature low enough to give you a slight sensation of cold, 75º or 80º.
I totally missed this point. I understand how cool water can have an awakening purpose, but one should feel comfortable and cosy in a bathtub full of warm water and bubbles. Am i right?
3rd. Amusing books.
Amen to that!
4th. Short views of human life – not further than dinner or tea.
And why is that? It’s kind of a vague suggestion. I would rather say one needs to see the good and the bad that people can give to you. And choose to be in the company of those who only give you positive vibes. That is when you’re the one who feels low. If you have positive thoughts to share you may use them to help others!
5th. Be as busy as you can.
Fine, but do not get stressed, I would add.
6th. See as much as you can of those friends who like and respect you.
Indeed. Also, you can send them an e-mail or text just to keep in touch!
7th. And of those acquaintances who amuse you.
Same as above. In modern times, sounds like Facebook!
8th. Make no secret of low spirits to your friends, but talk of them freely – they are always worse for dignified concealment.
True, and if you feel like it does not help, contact a psychologist. I don’t think they were as popular back then as they are now.
9th. Attend to the effects tea and coffee produce upon you.
Agree, but never depend on those. And do not rely on food to make you happier. It’s one thing to delight yourself from time to time, it’s another to obsess over food or drinks.
10th. Don’t expect too much from human life – a sorry business at the best.
Not completely true. How is this supposed to help someone who suffers from ‘low spirits’, dear Mr. Smith? I would have said that human life can be disappointing but one size does not fit all. Generalisation is almost never the right way to deal with things.
11th. Compare your lot with that of other people.
Especially those who have less. You must think positively, and once you’re better you might even help them!
12th. Avoid poetry, dramatic representations (except comedy), music, serious novels, melancholy, sentimental people, everything likely to excite feeling or emotion, not ending in active benevolence.
So, is suppressing emotions the right way to feel less melancholic? I don’t think melancholy is the product of emotions, it is an emotion itself. The debate should be on whether one has to suppress emotions or go through them in order to feel better. I tend to be in favour of the latter.
13th. DO GOOD, and endeavour to please everybody of every degree.
Whatever the best intentions are at play, one can only help others by helping oneself first. But yes, definitely agree on this one.
14th. Be as much as you can in the open air without fatigue.
Agree.
15th. Make the room where you commonly sit gay and pleasant.
Which means you should redecorate your room as you please, in case you haven’t paid much attention to it. In this age, one might also suggest to change something in the looks, be it the hairstyle or clothes. So, go buy yourself a new pair of shoes/trousers/shirts might also apply here. It’s proven to be a boost for one’s confidence.
16th. Struggle little by little against idleness.
And think about how much you could achieve every day.
17th. Don’t be too severe upon yourself, or underrate yourself, but do yourself justice.
Also, if you feel stressed, it probably means you’ve put yourself through too many things at once.
18th. Keep good blazing fires.
Ok!
19th. Be firm and constant in the exercise of rational religion.
Not sure I understand this point. However, if it’sit is essential to keep faith

20th. Believe me, dear Lady Georgiana, Very truly yours, Sydney Smith.

(Source: link. Also taken from: Hesketh Pearson, The Smith of Smiths, Hogarth Press, London, 1984. p.164)

19 Comments on “Fighting melancholy in the 21st Century

  1. afictionhabit
    28 April, 2012

    I really like this! You’re right, the rain has been pretty relentless over the last week or so, it just becomes so tedious. But back to the list; having struggled of late to get a grip of where I am in my life and what my next steps should be (realising I have been in unpaid employment looking after my children longer than I was ever in the workforce, and them not needing me quite as much as they used to), I have to constantly remind myself or actively seek out some of the things on this list. #11 is a good one to immediately remind me of my good fortune. But this weekend I am going on a walking weekend in the South Downs (yes really!) with some bookish friends, so can tick off the following from the list: #2 (although it will be rain rather than a shower/bath), #6,7,8,14,16. I hope to come home on Sunday evening in high spirits!

    • thebrightoldoak
      28 April, 2012

      Thank you. I wish you a wonderful weekend and a happy and pleasant start of the new week ;)

  2. mcfsantos
    28 April, 2012

    ;-)

    Very interesting approach on the subject!

    C.

  3. mcfsantos
    28 April, 2012

    Loved, loved your comments on every advice!
    (…)
    However, and according to Sydney Smith’s letter, how could one ever come close to anyone, when one of his advices was “Short views of human life- not further than dinner or tea.” ? Quite contradictable, ha?
    Well… maybe I’m asking this ’cause I know nothing about these 2 people, sorry! Other questions came up into my mind I don’t even dare putting into words…
    But.. well… being no. 20 an advice as well… “believe me, dear Lady Georgina..” I must smile and think twice about Mr. Smith’s “good” intentions… He reminded me so much of those men (and women) who try to keep their “beloved” ones far away from everything and everybody, both giving and stealing hope, manipulating, trying to tell: “I’m the cure for your pain”.
    Please… tell me I’m wrong… ’cause this list, not coming from a doctor (and it would be ridiculous, somehow), seems so… so… absurd! Oh, gosh! Women could already think in 1820! Or maybe not… Maybe Ladies couldn’t…

    Thanks for this!

    C.

    • thebrightoldoak
      28 April, 2012

      Thank you for liking my post, reblogging it and commenting on it. I’m really interested in your approach to the list and Smith’s intentions. I went the simplest route and thought his advice to be written to just help a friend out, but you could be right and it’s a perspective worth taking into account and write about!
      Or it could just be that Smith has shared his methods as universal whereas melancholy is probably something subjective. I commented on each point according to MY perspective but everyone’s different! x

      • mcfsantos
        28 April, 2012

        Sure!

        My critics didn’t rely on your viewpoint, but on Mr Smith’s letter and on the way he presented his advices…
        Anyway… those were other times and perhaps men tended to be over-protective towards their female friends… treating them like kids, or daughters or something…

        Furthermore I wrote at the very beginning of my comment that I “loved, loved your comments on every advice!” So we’re not that different!
        I simply thought some other ideas should be taken into account… But… I was perhaps overcritical…

        Thanks for answering and for being honest!

        C.

  4. mcfsantos
    28 April, 2012

    Reblogged this on nós and commented:
    Quite interesting approach on the subject “melancholy”, the so-called “low spirits”, back in 1820…

  5. Sigrun
    28 April, 2012

    Thank you, a great list & nice comments!
    Of the ones I have tried I sure can agree upon advice number 14. “Be as much as you can in the open air without fatigue”. (even in rain…)

  6. Barb Drummond
    28 April, 2012

    It is interesting how weather affects us. I grew up in australia in terror of heatwaves – I had some spectacular fainting attacks when the temperature got above a certain level. I loved the rain, loved walking in it, cycling in it. Really depends what you have to do – as long as there’s a warm dry place at the end, getting a good soaking feels great. But now I seem to get upset by rain and really crave strong winds – as a cyclist I used to fear them, but now they give me a lot of energy.

    • thebrightoldoak
      28 April, 2012

      Great insight into weather related feelings Barb. I think it mostly depends on the way one’s grown up, where they lived and different situations in their lives that are associated with weather! x

  7. Very Becoming
    28 April, 2012

    Loved the post. In the states we’ve been having a severe lack of rain. Everyone is happy with the weather and feels active and alive (a symptom of spring), but they are ignoring the fact that no rain means severe drought. We may not like the rain, but New Jersey certainly needs it right now.

    I don’t know that Smith means that we should suppress our emotions when he suggests avoiding poetry and serious novels. I think he means that when we already feel melancholy, we probably shouldn’t read anything that will exacerbate that emotion and make us hopeless and sigh and wallow in our melancholy as opposed to doing something about it. We should read things that make us feel vigorous!

    And with his suggestion of having a short view of human life, I think he’s proposing that we should only consider the day at hand. Thinking too far ahead can, perhaps, make someone long for a better day.

    I thought his suggestion about not expecting too much from human life to be funny. In a Jane Austen novel a character travels to visit with other people in the village to be taken out of herself, but she is often dissapointed to find that idle chatter and gossip that people want to pursue do not help her mood. Perhaps Smith means that we have to be sure that we can make ourselves happy, that we cannot expect others to do this for us.

  8. thebrightoldoak
    28 April, 2012

    Thank you, VB. I’m thinking Smith may have had something true in his intentions, but as another poster highlighted, it could be that there are different views to consider when it comes to his ultimate purpose. And as I have said before, that list can be analysed and seen under different lights. Thank you and all the other posters, as you’ve certainly broadened my views on a subject, as always :) x

  9. Mrs. N
    5 May, 2012

    Great post and wonderful comments! I could relate to much of it. Almost all. If I commented on everything that I related to I’d write several pages here on your comments section…but…it’s late :) Suffice it to say that I enjoyed this post and gave me some food for thought.

  10. Alethea Eason
    5 May, 2012

    I enjoyed reading this and how you compared the possible 21st century contexts of what he was saying. I love rain. I feel most creative when the weather is bad and I don’t have any place to go other than to my writing desk or art table. Sometimes relentless days of sun, as we have here in northern California between June and October, sometimes into November, can create melancholy in me. But that may be more due to temps in the 90s day after day after day. Today we have a real spring day and everything seems perfect.

    • thebrightoldoak
      6 May, 2012

      I completely understand what you mean. Even the driest weather can cause some sort of unbearable frustration at times. It’s balance that one misses the most, isn’t it?

  11. Sunelly_Sims
    18 May, 2012

    Great post – you have a very interesting blog!
    Thanks for visit on my “Photos On The Go” and for sharing your thounghts!
    Now, your blog is on my reader :-)

    Greetings,
    Sunelly Sims

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Information

This entry was posted on 28 April, 2012 by in Culture & Society, Literature, People and tagged , , , , , .
Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 731 other followers

%d bloggers like this: